I nailed the interview… so why did nothing happen? 😅
If you’ve ever wrapped a podcast interview feeling so good about it—like, “okay yeah, that went really well!”—and then… nothing
No new leads, no sales, no obvious spike in your business
That’s not abnormal; it’s something I see happen to a lot of online business owners who don’t have a solid podcast guesting plan
Podcast guesting can be really powerful for your marketing… and it can also go wrong really easily if you’re mostly doing it for the cred of ‘being on a podcast’ instead of building an actual podcast guesting plan that’s designed to create real ROI 🙃
News flash: being featured isn’t the same thing as getting results! If you’re aiming for leads, sales, and business growth, you need more than a great conversation and a vague hope that it’ll all magically connect somehow. What often happens is people try to fix the whole thing with more
More pitches, more bookings, more interviews… and then they’re confused when it turns into a ton of work that still doesn’t create traction in their marketing and sales 🤔
We’re gonna talk about three things that create a solid foundation for your podcast guesting plan:
- Why 90 days is the sweet spot for a podcast guesting plan
- Why more pitches doesn’t automatically mean better results
- And what strategic podcast guesting looks like at a high level—so your guesting stops feeling random and starts feeling repeatable
Why a 90-day podcast guesting plan is the sweet spot
Here’s the part that doesn’t get talked about enough: podcast guesting has a built-in lag
There’s a delay between when you start pitching and when you start seeing results, even when you’re doing everything in a solid, thoughtful way
First you pitch…
Then you wait and follow up and schedule and record, and then… 😃
You wait again… 😑 and usually you’re restarting the process with other shows while you’re in that waiting game
And then even when the episode finally goes live, that still doesn’t automatically mean you’re about to get a flood of leads and sales! Especially if you’re in the online B2B space—course creators, membership owners, service providers—where people don’t typically hear you once and immediately buy. A lot of the time, they listen… then they might follow you… then maybe they join your email list 🤷♀️
They need to hear you multiple times before the trust really clicks, though, and the timing has to be right before they buy. That’s why a couple weeks of a big ole podcast sprint doesn’t necessarily translate into results, even if you do get booked on a few shows
It’s like planting seeds on a Monday and being mad at your garden by Friday because you don’t have tomatoes yet 😵💫 It takes time… and it takes intentionality
A 90-day podcast guesting plan gives you enough runway for the pitching, the scheduling, the recording, the publishing lag, and the trust lag
It’s what lets podcast guesting actually start to shine—because you’re giving the process enough time to do what it does!
The “more pitches” trap inside your podcast guesting plan
A lot of people fall into this idea that more pitches automatically equals more bookings. And yeah, sure, pitching more podcasts can get you more bookings, because it can be a numbers game sometimes. The problem is, more bookings doesn’t automatically mean more results for your business 😅
If you’re not being intentional about what you’re pitching, you can end up doing a whole bunch of podcast interviews that feel productive, but don’t actually bring in the leads you were hoping for
This is where podcast guesting starts to feel like a scam for folks. It’s not because podcast guesting doesn’t work, though, but because they’re putting in a ton of effort and not seeing anything come from it, so they decide the whole thing is stupid and a waste of time
Most of the time, what’s actually happening is they’re getting booked on shows that aren’t a great fit. That means they’re talking to people who might think they’re interesting, but they’re not the people who would ever become their clients 😭
So of course it feels like it doesn’t work! The outcome you’re measuring is leads and sales, but the inputs you’re choosing don’t really support that
And I want to be super clear here, because this is where people get weird about being “strategic”… this isn’t about making every podcast interview a sales pitch, or turning it into an infomercial, or trying to manipulate people into buying from you
I’m just talking about making sure your podcast guesting plan is designed to create the kind of results you actually want. ‘Cause if you don’t have that foundation, then “more pitches” just means “more work”—and you’re still stuck wondering why nothing is happening 🫠
What “strategic podcast guesting” actually means in your podcast guesting plan
Okay, so when I say “strategic podcast guesting,” I’m not talking about turning every interview into some weird sales presentation. I’m not talking about making the host regret inviting you because you spent 40 minutes talking about yourself and your offer and your offer and your offer 🙈
Strategic podcast guesting just means you’re being intentional about three things:
👉 Where you show up
👉 What you talk about
👉 And what happens after the episode goes live
That’s it! It’s not super duper complicated, but it’s also not what most people do. Most people approach podcast guesting like, “Cool, I got booked!” then after airs, they share it one time and they’re like, “Alright, anyway… moving on!”
When that approach doesn’t create the results they wanted, they assume podcast guesting is the issue 🙄 But a lot of the time, the real issue is that their podcast guesting plan is missing the pieces that make it work as marketing!
A great conversation is only part of the plan. You also need the conversation to be happening in front of the right people, in a way that naturally connects to what you do, and then you need a simple follow-through system so the episode doesn’t just vanish into the void 24 hours later
And that’s where having the right fit comes in, because fit is the foundation of a podcast guesting plan that creates business growth 💪
Fit is the foundation of a profitable podcast guesting plan
If you want podcast guesting to create real business growth, fit is going to be the thing that makes or breaks it. Yeah, you can get attention from people who aren’t a fit, and it may feel nice… but it won’t turn into leads and sales (and that’s what we all want, right?)
Fit is what helps the right people recognize, “Oh wow… yeah, that’s me! 🤩” It’s what helps them connect the dots without you having to push them into a sale
And when I talk about fit, I’m talking about two different types:
👉 Audience fit
👉 And topic fit
1 | Audience fit
Audience fit is about whether the people listening are the people who could actually become your clients. So for example, if your people are course creators who need a sales funnel… and you go on a podcast that talks to anyone and everyone who has a business 🛑
You’re gonna get people who may give you props for a good interview. They may even walk away with some a-ha moments! But if they’re not the kind of people who will end up working with you, what was the point? 🤦♀️
If your goal is leads and sales, that’s going to feel like podcast guesting doesn’t work, because the people who would buy from you weren’t really in the room
2 | Topic fit
Topic fit is about whether the conversation you’re going to have on that show naturally connects to what you do. We’re not doing that in a forced way; we want it to make sense so someone listening can easily take the next step with us 🥰
If the topic doesn’t match, you’re gonna end up having to shoehorn in your offer into the interview… and we don’t want to be doing that 😅
You want to have a podcast guesting plan that feels good and doesn’t feel salesy… but still gets people interested in what you have to offer! That’s the sweet spot we’re aiming for
A few quick Mic Check™ questions to make fit obvious
This is the kind of thing Mic Check™ helps you do—so you can avoid going on podcasts that might get you attention, but don’t get you ROI
Ask yourself: Would my people recognize themselves in this conversation?
Like, would they listen and think, “Yep… that’s my problem” or “that’s the thing I’ve been trying to figure out”? Is there a natural place for your offer to fit into the conversation? You want the topic to naturally create a gap that your offer solves. If someone loves this episode, is it realistic that they’d want more from you, or are they more likely to just be like, “That was good,” and move on? 🤔
That’s why the goal isn’t to be everywhere. The goal is to be in the places where the trust transfer actually matters, and where the audience is primed to take action
That’s part of why I don’t create huge podcast lists for my No-Fuss Podcast Tour™ clients! I’d rather focus it in so you’re pitching a tighter set of shows that actually make sense for your business, because that’s what creates real results. If you’ve been focusing on quantity over quality, now’s the time to flip that
Podcast guesting ROI doesn’t always show up immediately
This is the part that makes people throw their hands up and declare, “podcast guesting doesn’t work” 😭
They do the interview, feel like they did a great job, and then they wait for the payoff… and it’s crickets
But more often than not, the issue isn’t that podcast guesting doesn’t work! It’s just that you’re expecting immediate leads and sales from something that often has a delayed impact—especially in the online B2B space
For a lot of us B2B online business owners, the first sign of ROI isn’t a sale. It could be things like a new follower, a new email subscriber, a quick DM, a collaboration connection, or someone who now has you filed away in their brain as “that person who knows what they’re talking about” 😌 (but you never hear about that, so… yeah)
That all matters more than people want to admit, because that’s what gets people to buy in the long-run. They’ll listen to an episode while they’re driving or doing dishes or walking their dog, and they might not do anything about it in the moment… but then they think about it the next day
So they follow you on Instagram, and then you post something a week later that gives them another a-ha moment. Which gets them to join your email list (yay!). And then a little later, you send an email that’s the perfect thing at the perfect time… and now they buy! 🎉
You might not be able to track that back to the podcast, unless you’re tagging your leads or tracking where they came from some other way, so it can feel like the podcast did nothing, even when it was the catalyst for it all
So yes, this still counts as ROI from podcast guesting!
If podcast guesting helped someone find you, remember you, trust you, or take a step toward you… that’s your podcast guesting plan doing its job 🙌
And this is exactly why fit matters so much, too! When you’re in front of the right people, it’s not just “that was interesting” energy—it’s “oh wait… I need this” energy 😍
The part most DIY podcast guesting plans skip: follow-through
Now, there’s a part I see so many people skip, and it’s a big one 😬 If you do this part well, it’s what turns podcast guesting into evergreen marketing instead of a one-time moment that disappears after you post it once
A lot of people treat getting booked and showing up as the finish line
They record the interview, the episode airs, they share it one time, and then they move on with their lives 👋
But podcasts don’t work like an Instagram Story! They don’t expire in 24 hours (thank heaven). There are new people discovering podcasts every day, which means there are new people discovering your episode every day, too!
So if your follow-through is “post it once and pray 🤞” you’re basically taking something that could keep working for you and turning it into a one-day event (which is totally not what podcast guesting is fooooor)
If you’re already putting in the effort to pitch, prep, record, and show up, you should squeeze out more juice, not toss the oranges in the trash, okay? 🍊
Follow-through involves a few simple things:
👉 Staying in touch with the host, because you genuinely never know what that relationship could lead to
👉 Keeping a simple way to track what you pitched, what you booked, what you recorded, and what went live
👉 And continuing to pitch new shows so you’ve always got seeds being planted while earlier seeds are starting to sprout 🌱
If you keep slowly but surely planting seeds, but the time you get to the end of the row and circle back, the first seeds you planted could already be bearing fruit for you! (Look, I know that’s not how gardening actually works, but roll with me)
That’s what a real podcast guesting plan does—it creates momentum you can sustain long enough to see results 👀
What to include in a 90-day podcast guesting plan (so it’s actually sustainable)
So now that we’ve talked about the runway, the fit, and why the ROI can be delayed… let’s talk about what actually belongs inside a 90-day podcast guesting plan
The goal isn’t to hype yourself up for one big push and then ghost your own plan two weeks later 👻 The goal is to build something you can keep doing in a way that feels doable in real life
A solid 90-day podcast guesting plan is basically three buckets:
👉 A fit filter (so you’re not pitching random shows)
👉 A pitching rhythm (so you’re consistently planting those seeds)
👉 A follow-through system (so the episodes don’t disappear after they air)
And none of these need to be complicated—they just need to exist 😜
1 | A fit filter (aka your Mic Check)
This is where your Mic Check comes in again! Once you can recognize what make a podcast a Yes or a No, you’re not guessing every time you find a new show. Now you’re pitching based on alignment—audience fit and topic fit—and whether it makes sense for your business goals
This alone changes everything, because it protects you from the “sure, I’ll do anything” era of podcast guesting 😊
2 | A pitching rhythm you can actually keep up with
This is where people get in their own way, because they think if they’re not pitching a million podcasts a week, they’re not “doing it right” 🤨
But a podcast guesting plan doesn’t have to be aggressive to be effective! Consistency often matters way more than intensity
Pitching two shows a week, every week, for 90 days is a plan
Pitching twenty shows in one weekend and then avoiding your inbox for a month… is a panic response 😱
The reason the smaller, consistent rhythm works is because you’re building momentum you can sustain. It means you can keep your client pipeline moving forward
You’re giving yourself the chance to get booked regularly, record regularly, and have episodes go live regularly… which means you don’t end up with that whiplash effect where nothing is happening for weeks—and then suddenly you’re booked on five shows in one month and you’re drowning 🛟
Also, pitching is not the only thing that takes time here! Don’t forget about the outreach, follow-up, scheduling, prep, guest forms, recording, and then the follow-through. I’m not saying that to scare you, but when you set your rhythm, it has to match your actual capacity, so don’t focus on just the pitching aspect
3 | A follow-through system that keeps working after you hit record
This is the part that makes podcast guesting feel like evergreen marketing instead of a one-time thing. Remember: your episode doesn’t stop existing after launch week!
Because of that, your follow-through system needs to cover two things:
👉 First: what you do when an episode goes live
Like sharing it (obviously), but also knowing what you’re doing beyond a single post so it doesn’t just disappear into thin air
👉 Second: what you do to keep the pipeline flowing while episodes are airing
You want your guesting to become this steady background engine in your marketing, not a dramatic on-again, off-again relationship
I promise you don’t need a 47-step repurposing plan for this to work. I just want you to make a plan you’ll actually follow 🤪
It could be as simple as: “I’m going to share every episode on IG more than once, and I’m going to keep track of where I’ve been so I can keep building relationships with the hosts afterward”
That’s already a huge upgrade from “post it and forget it”!
The simplest version of a 90-day podcast guesting plan
If you want to keep this really clean, here’s what you’re aiming for:
👉 Pick the kinds of shows you’re going to pitch using Mic Check
👉 Choose a pitching rhythm you can stick to for 90 days
👉 Track what you pitched, what got booked, what got recorded, and what went live
👉 And make sure you’re following through after the episode airs so it keeps working for you
That’s a podcast guesting plan! You’re no longer relying on vibes, hopes, or a random sprint 🙌
Common mistakes that sabotage your podcast guesting plan
Even if you say you want a strategic, sustainable podcast guesting plan, it’s so easy to accidentally build something that guarantees you’ll burn out… or guarantees you’ll get “results” that don’t actually lead to leads
Here are some of the mistakes I see most often. We’ve touched on a bunch of them already, but they bear a quick review:
1 | Treating podcast guesting like a sprint instead of a system
Folks get a burst of motivation, pitch a bunch of shows all at once, and then they’re like, “Okay I did it! 😁”
Buuuuut then they don’t follow up, they don’t keep going, and they don’t build any momentum out of it (whoops 🙃)
The problem is, podcast guesting rewards consistency, not intensity. A sprint might get you some podcast bookings, but it doesn’t create the kind of steady pipeline that makes guesting feel like it’s actually working
If you’ve been approaching this as “I just need to do a big push and then I’ll be set,” hate to break it to ya, but that’s probably why it keeps fizzling out
2 | Prioritizing quantity over quality
This is where people get sucked into the “numbers game” mindset. And again, yes, there is a numbers element to pitching… but the quality piece still matters as much or more
If you’re pitching anything with a microphone and a Spotify listing, you’re going to end up on shows that don’t have the right audience fit or topic fit. Then you’ll be doing interviews that won’t create the kind of business growth you actually want
If you want a podcast guesting plan that creates leads, the goal isn’t “more podcasts.” The goal is “more of the right podcasts” 👍
3 | Letting someone else pitch for you without a real strategy (or without your Mic Check)
I’m gonna say this with love, because I know there are services out there that promise the world…
But if someone is pitching you to a massive list of random shows, that is not a podcast guesting plan!
That’s just outreach volume, and while you can absolutely get booked that way, you can also absolutely end up doing a ton of interviews that don’t go anywhere, because the shows weren’t aligned in the first place 🫠
This is part of why I don’t build giant podcast lists for No-Fuss Podcast Tour clients. I’d rather have you pitch a strategic, smaller group of shows that make sense, because that’s what creates real ROI for your business
4 | Using a generic pitch and hoping the host “gets it”
You write one pitch, copy/paste it a hundred times, and you’re like, “Look at me being productive—wheeeeeeee!”
But hosts can tell when they’re getting a template. (Believe me; they’ve shown me the bad ones enough times 😜) And even if they don’t consciously clock it, it still creates this vibe of “this person doesn’t really care about or know my show”
A podcast guesting plan works best when your pitches are actually aligned with the show you’re reaching out to!
5 | Treating the interview like the finish line
This is the one that turns podcast guesting into a one-time moment instead of evergreen marketing 🌲
If your plan stops at “get booked, record, post it once,” then yeah… it’s going to feel like podcast guesting doesn’t work. You’re doing all the upfront work and then barely using the asset you created
But listen, Linda: your episode doesn’t expire! Your follow-through usually does, though, and that’s where the ball’s getting dropped 😬
6 | Tracking nothing and then assuming it “didn’t work”
If you don’t track anything, podcast guesting can feel like you’re throwing spaghetti at the wall in the dark. When you can’t immediately point to a sale, you assume the whole thing was a waste 🤷♀️
But we already talked about how ROI from podcast guesting can be delayed. There’s a lag time between pitch → booking → the episode airing. So if you don’t have even a basic way to connect “this person came from this show,” you’re probably underestimating what’s working!
When you underestimate what’s working, you’re more likely to quit the plan that would’ve worked if you’d just kept going… and that sucks 😭
Your podcast guesting plan doesn’t need to be complicated
If podcast guesting has felt random, or disappointing, or like you’re putting in way more effort than you’re getting back… it’s usually not because you’re doing something “wrong” on the interview itself. It’s usually because you don’t have a podcast guesting plan that’s built for the way podcast guesting actually works
That’s why I’m such a fan of the 90-day podcast guesting plan timeframe
It gives you enough time to pitch, follow up, get booked, record, have episodes go live, and actually let the trust build. It also keeps you from falling into the trap of “more more more” as the solution 😉
So if you’re sitting there thinking, “Okay… I want podcast guesting to work, but I don’t want it to take over my life,” you’re in the right place! 💚 And if you want help mapping the whole thing out, I’ve got’cha covered
0 Comments